The Cult of the Rite
March 26, 2013 § Leave a comment
From Wikipedia:
In the specific context of Greek hero cult, Carla Antonaccio has written, “The term cult identifies a pattern of ritual behavior in connection with specific objects, within a framework of spatial and temporal coordinates. Ritual behavior would include (but not necessarilly be limited to) prayer, sacrifice, votive offerings, competitions, processions and construction of monuments. Some degree of recurrence in place and repetition over time of ritual action is necessary for cult to be enacted, to be practiced”[1]2
To what extent can we view the 20th, and now 21st century, practice of recreating, performing, and witnessing The Rite of Spring, this faux ritual suicide, as a cult? How does our 100-year practice of reenacting this mythical rite (or refusing to reenact it by changing key aspects of the original libretto) satisfy Antonaccio’s criteria for cult worship?
The latin root of the word cult, cultus, means “care” or “adoration.” Lovers adore/care for one another every day in countless gestures. Similarly, worshippers care for the values they hold dearly by practicing devotion to deities or other forces that embody or otherwise represent these values.
Note to self: could easily devote multiple sets of 12 to this topic. Non-stop writing for 12 minutes at a time is a mainstay of my current writing practice. Is it devotional? Let’s ask Antonaccio.
1 Antonaccio, “Contesting the Past: Hero Cult, Tomb Cult, and Epic in Early Greece”, American Journal of Archaeology 98.3 (July 1994: 389-410) p. 398.
2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cult_(religious_practice). I like the brief etymology presented here. Would be good to cross reference with some others.
What’s in a name?
March 13, 2013 § Leave a comment
[this entry is in process]
The piece with many names.
The original Russian name was not used at the world premiere of this piece. I’m curious how Diaghilev and his collaborators landed upon the particular translation they used in French, and at what point they began referring to it by its Russian name. I wonder how they referred to it among themselves. Go back to the Diaghilev biography for clues in their correspondence between Stravinsky and Diaghilev. Of course the name could have changed monikers at any point and probably at many points in its life even within this one company: after Nijinsky, during Massine’s tenure, after Diaghilev, etc. And of course different people likely referred to it with different names. At the time the collaborators were mostly Russians fluent in French and thus fully aware of the different implications of its differing names in those two languages. How fluent in French were they actually?
Other than Paris the only other place that the original piece played was London, thus requiring an English name. I wonder how they came up with the English translation and how fluent the translators were both with language and with the piece.
German: Fruhlingsopfer
Opfer in Google translate…
noun
|
|||
victim
|
Opfer, Geschädigte, Verunglückte
|
||
sacrifice
|
Opfer, Opferung, Verzicht, Opfergabe
|
||
offering
|
Opfer, Gabe, Opfergabe, Kollekte, Vorstellung
|
||
oblation
|
Opfer, Opfergabe
|
||
prey
|
Beute, Opfer, Raub
|
||
casualty
|
Opfer, Unfallopfer, Verletzte, Todesopfer, Verunglückte, Verwundete
|
Wearing a Suicide Vest
January 23, 2013 § Leave a comment
I found three intriguing stories of women and girls wearing suicide belt/vests. Somehow all three of these individuals survived their ordeals, perhaps intentionally to sow fear by publicizing such events rather than actually performing them. Performance for the media rather than in actuality. The third event below raised questions in the blogosphere about whether it might have been staged by Jordan officials.
- Sohana Jawed, 9 year old kidnap victim in Pakistan: http://www.indianexpress.com/news/9yearold-pak-girl-forced-to-wear-suicide-vest/806402/1
- Rania, 15 year old in Iraq: http://adjunct.diodon349.com/Attack_on_USA/dramatic_moment_a_15year_od_iraqi_suicide_bomber_gave_herself_up.htm,
and http://www.odt.co.nz/news/galleries/gallery/19537/iraqi-girl-caught-with-bomb-vest
- Sajida Mubarek Atrous al-Rishawi, Iraqi native who is reported to have survived her attempt to bomb a wedding in Jordan: http://www.bagnewsnotes.com/2005/11/vested-interest/
It is important to me to include here the names of these individuals, to personalize their stories. Divorced of their names, such stories become abstractions and all the easier to fear and to exaggerate. Including the names helps me focus my attention on their material reality, and helps me focus on the experience of these individuals and on their particular circumstances.
Perhaps on Friday’s performance of Embodying the Rites, 1.3 I should stage a fashion show for the cameras like that staged for Jordanian television featuring Ms. Rishawi and the explosive belt she is alleged to have worn in a botched attempt to blow herself up at a wedding.
The Wicker Man Gender Bender
July 4, 2012 § Leave a comment
The 1973 horror film The Wicker Man bends theme of virgin sacrifice to the sun around a male sacrifice. A late 20th century community has lured a detective to their remote island for the purpose of sacrificing him in tribute to the sun so that their harvest may be more bountiful than in previous years. The chosen one is burned in the wicker form of a human, in a gesture reminiscent of Druid battle practices.
I am curious whether any of the articles emerging from the three-day conference (hosted in 2003 by the Crichton Campus of the University of Glasgow in Dumfries and Galloway) discuss the relationship between this story and The Golden Bough. Must get my hands on the two collections of articles which emerged from this conference.
Lal Bibi, a dead person seeking life
July 4, 2012 § 4 Comments
Sometimes we humans sacrifice young women as atonement for crimes they have nothing to do with — not just on stage, but in real life.
According to her family, 18 year old Lal Bibi was abducted from her home in northern Afghanistan by five local police officers and then raped and beaten for five days before being dumped back at her family’s home. Her suffering seems to have been meant as payback for the actions of her cousin, which seem to have involved the daughter of one of the policemen’s brother. Some reports claim that this other young woman was also raped; some reports claim that Lal Bibi’s cousin fell in love with and attempted to elope with this policeman’s niece. In any case, the cousin absconded and thus the girl’s family could not punish him directly, as their anger at his relationship with their daughter might have demanded.
In Afghan tribal custom families sometimes agree to settle disputes with payment of livestock, money, or a bride. Such a settlement is known as badal. The policeman’s family seems to have extracted its payment of badal by force, and Lal Bibi’s family has responded with the rare step of seeking justice through governmental channels and going public with their story. In many instances her family would simply have killed her as a now tainted blot on their family honor that would endure for generations. Lal Bibi has reportedly said that she will kill herself if the government does not restore her honor by punishing her abductors: “They took me by force… If I receive justice, that’s good, otherwise I’m going to burn and kill myself.” Her own mother has also threatened to sacrifice her daughter if justice is not served: “Either you deliver us justice, or the blood of my daughter will be on your hands,” she said. “Either you burn my daughter yourself, or I will throw petrol over her and burn her to get justice.”
Death by fire is an powerful statement of sacrifice. It is a dramatic gesture that does not simply end a life, but ends it with excruciating pain that endures over time. If victims do not succumb to smoke inhalation, death can take as long as 2 hours.
It seems that according to tribal custom, Lal Bibi’s life ended when she was forcibly married and raped. But that other events might restore that life. Her life has already been sacrificed to atone for that of another young woman. None of the reports I have found mention the welfare of this other young woman, although the most recent report indicates that the amorous cousin is currently in custody along with four of Lal Bibi’s alleged kidnappers.
This shocking story is stimulating an overwhelming international demand for justice. Certainly notions of justice here are complex and perhaps inscrutable to outsiders. The Afghan government is working to mollify an overwhelming sense that local police forces are lawless and out of control. On the level of national politics this event is a public relations problem, which points to major defects in local governance and civil rights. A young woman is ready to take her own life because she has been raped. A young man sensed danger and fled, leaving his family to suffer the revenge of an angry father for whatever transpired between him and another young woman.
What seems to be unique here is not that an innocent young woman is sacrificed in payment for the sins of another, but that she and her family are seeking an outcome other than her inevitable death. And as a result her plight has become international news. Cases of young women offered as badal are common — how common is unclear. The righteous indignation of outsiders at this inscrutable practice is common. How can we understand the logic that demands the death of an innocent for the death of another innocent? How can we understand our insatiable hunger for such stories? Do we not consume these stories with an obscene voraciousness that rehearses and perpetuates their violence (Time magazine cover story, August 2010)? Can our righteous signing of international petitions actually restore life for a young woman who considers herself dead (“I am already a dead person“)? Does external condemnation of a system of justice not serve to strengthen that system — particularly when that condemnation comes from an untrusted occupying force? What is the nature of a self that considers itself dead when it has been offended? What is the nature of agency in a system where families rather than individuals seek justice on behalf of family representatives, and where family representatives can atone for sins of other family members? How do conflicting systems of justice coexist and influence one another?
Read more:
- http://www.rferl.org/content/rape-case-tests-afghan-justice/24604549.html
- http://alaiwah.wordpress.com/2012/06/09/18-year-old-lal-bibi-raped-in-afghanistan-by-the-police/
- http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/28/world/asia/afghan-rape-case-turns-focus-on-local-police.html?pagewanted=all
[Note to self:
Consider this story in light of social theorists writing about sacrifice (scapegoat, ending cycle of violence etc)].
The Giving of Oneself Altogether and Finally
May 26, 2012 § Leave a comment
Wendy Perriman traces the intimate relationship that novelist Willa Cather had with concert dance in the early 20th Century. The chapter “Shadows on the Rock: The Giving of Oneself Altogether and Finally” describes Ballets Russes works that Cather attended and which influenced her writing, including the Rite of Spring.
Willa Cather and the Dance: “A Most Satisfying Elegance”
Moloch and the circulation of Myth
March 7, 2012 § Leave a comment
Moloch (also Molech, Molekh, Molok, Molek, Molock, Moloc, or simply the letter combination MLK) is the alleged name of an ancient Ammonite god with the head of a bull. Worship to this god in the form of propitiatory child and animal sacrifice — particularly by fire — has been attributed to Canaanites, Phoenician and related cultures in North Africa and the Levant.
Awkwardly, accounts of these bloody rituals have been written by enemies of these peoples, thus it seems impossible to know the context of these activities or whether they actually occurred. Accounts of these rituals are as suspect as the Spanish accounts of Aztec sacrifice during the time when Spanish military officers were trying to gain Spanish support for their activities suppressing the people they encountered in The New World. Subsequent archeological discoveries have made it clear that some sort of human sacrifice was indeed practiced by the Aztecs perhaps even in forms reminiscent of the vivid descriptions in Spanish drawings and written accounts.
Archeological evidence of Moloch worship is much less clear. Read more here:
What interests me is the life of such myths and their potency for the people who circulate them.
To do:
- Think about circulation of the Moloch story among the Israelites who published the first written references to this god as prohibitions. Israelites were specifically told not to participate in such sacrifices. Why? Were they prone to? Or were the authors of the text simply establishing an other against which to define themselves?The Moloch image continues to be repeated as fact and placed in association with contemporary issues to serve various contemporary political agendas:
The ancients would heat this idol up with fire until it was glowing, then they would take their newborn babies, place them on the arms of the idol, and watch them burn to death. I can’t help but compare today’s abortion massacre to the sacrifice of children by these ancient pagans. In both, innocent life is destroyed for the gain of the parent.
(http://carm.org/christianity/miscellaneous-topics/moloch-ancient-pagan-god-child-sacrifice)
- Think about circulation of The Rite of Spring. This story is entirely manufactured based on an imagined “pagan Russia” and inspired by the roundly discredited theories of The Golden Bough, which circulated widely in the decades before The Rite of Spring emerged.
We cannot learn about the characters or cultures described in the myth, because the myth does not reliably point to a particular source. But we can learn about those who create, consume and circulate it.
Related:
The Munich Cosmic Circle was a group of writers and intellectuals in Germany associated with the mystic Alfred Schuler.
“They developed a doctrine according to which the West was plagued by downfall and degeneration, caused by the rationalizing and demythologizing effects of Christianity. A way out of this desolate state could, according to the “Cosmic” view, only be found by a return to pagan origins.” (wikipedia)
This urge toward (some imagined) pagan roots similarly motivates both The Golden Bough and The Rite of Spring. These urges also inspired the back-to-the-earth experiments of the artists and intellectuals at Monte Verita, where Rudolf Laban staged his first community movement ritual, Ode to the Sun in 1913.
Aside:
“In writings of the so-called Munich Cosmic Circle the name Moloch was used to symbolize a hostile to life, emotionally cold and intellectualist principle.” (wikipedia citation: Karl und Hanna Wolfskehl – Briefwechsel mit Friedrich Gundolf. Edited by Karlhans Kluncker. Castrum Peregrini Presse, 1977 ISBN 9060340329)
More Moloch:
http://www.pantheon.org/articles/m/moloch.html
http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10443b.htm
http://carm.org/christianity/miscellaneous-topics/moloch-ancient-pagan-god-child-sacrifice
http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/10937-moloch-molech
http://peterjfast.com/2012/02/16/moloch-an-appetite-for-children/